Regulators approve $40.3 million of Peoples Gas’ $144 million rate request

The Illinois Commerce Commission cut about 72% from Peoples Gas' rate request and kept the 2035 pipe deadline. Here is what the ruling means for Uptown households and businesses heading into winter.

By Dana Ferraro · 3 min read
·

The Peoples Gas Building at 122 S. Michigan Ave., completed in 1911 for the gas utility. Photo: John G. Suhayda / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Peoples Gas customers in Uptown will see a smaller increase in the delivery part of their bills than the utility wanted, after state regulators approved $40.3 million of the company’s $144 million rate request on Thursday.

The Illinois Commerce Commission said in a Nov. 19 release that it struck $103.7 million from the request, a cut of about 72%. It also set the return on equity Peoples Gas may earn at 9.48%, below the 10.1% the company sought. The commission did the same for sister utility North Shore Gas, which serves the northern suburbs, approving about $1.9 million of an $8.7 million request.

For Uptown’s apartment buildings, storefronts and restaurants, all of which heat with gas delivered by Peoples, the ruling arrives just as the heating season starts. The ICC said the effect on any one bill will depend on the customer’s service class and how much gas it uses.

What the commission decided

The case, ICC dockets 26-0065 and 26-0066, ran for 11 months. Peoples Gas first asked for $202 million before lowering the request to $144 million, and the commission’s administrative law judges had proposed $66.2 million last month, Capitol News Illinois reported. The full request would have added an average of $7 to $8 a month to household bills, according to the same report, and the company said it was still calculating the effect of the smaller increase, which begins in December.

“Affordability and risk reduction are critical concerns in any ICC utility proceeding,” ICC Chairman Doug Scott said in the commission’s release. He called the approved increase “a fair and reasonable determination reached over the course of an 11-month legal proceeding.”

Much of the money at stake is tied to the utility’s pipe retirement program. The ICC previously ordered Peoples Gas to retire its cast-iron and ductile-iron gas mains by 2035 and set up a safety monitor to track the work. The commission kept that deadline in place but told the company to look at alternatives to full replacement, including relining pipes and options that avoid new pipe altogether. It plans to review progress after the safety monitor’s March 2027 report.

Peoples Gas called the decision “surprising and extremely disappointing” and said it would cut $25 million in day-to-day safety work, according to Capitol News Illinois.

The city’s role, and help for customers

The City of Chicago took part in the case. In a Nov. 20 statement, Mayor Brandon Johnson’s office said the city’s Law and Environment departments worked with the Illinois Attorney General’s office, the Citizens Utility Board and Illinois PIRG to argue against the increase. “Yesterday’s decision from the ICC is a win for Chicago families who already face too great a burden in energy costs,” Johnson said.

The order also keeps a requirement from 2023 that Peoples Gas and North Shore Gas offer a low-income discount aimed at holding gas costs to 3% of a household’s income, a common measure of energy affordability. The ICC said both utilities must update the discount tiers each October and whenever new rates take effect, and it urged customers who are struggling to apply for the state’s Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program and check whether they qualify for the utility’s discount.

Utility costs have been a running issue for Chicago renters this fall. WBEZ reported this week on tenants facing higher gas and water charges as more landlords pass costs through with a billing method that divides a building’s bill among units.

For small businesses, the gas bill lands on top of other costs we have been tracking, including the proposed increase in Chicago’s lease tax. Neighborhood merchants are also getting ready for Winter Walk on Wilson on Dec. 4. More on local business costs is on our Business page.

Customers with questions about a bill or a utility dispute can call the ICC’s consumer line at 800-524-0795. The commission’s next look at the pipe program comes with the March 2027 safety monitor report.

Dana Ferraro covers property taxes, small business finance and the economy.

More Business